Human Rights Activist Kimutai Kirui Sues Eldoret Blogger Over Alleged Defamatory Publications

0

The latest case places Kiplagat at the centre of two separate civil proceedings involving allegations of defamatory social media publications within a matter of weeks.

Picture-4-1-Picsart-AiImageEnhancer

Human Right Activist Kimutai Kirui at the Eldoret High Court

By HubzMedia

Renowned human rights activist and governance advocate Benard Kimutai Kirui has sued an Eldoret-based blogger and employee of Moi Teaching and Referral Hospital (MTRH), Joshua Kiplagat, over alleged defamatory publications circulated through WhatsApp groups and other social media platforms.

The suit, filed at the Eldoret Magistrate Court, comes weeks after another individual, Boniface Kipchumba Biwott, brought separate defamation proceedings against Kiplagat over allegedly offensive social media posts.

In the case Benard Kimutai Kirui v Joshua Kiplagat, registered as MCCC/E2472/2026, Kirui accuses the respondent of publishing statements that he says falsely portrayed him as a criminal, questioned his integrity and linked him to alleged misconduct involving proceedings at the International Criminal Court (ICC).

Court documents show that Kirui filed a Notice of Motion dated October 2, 2026, supported by an affidavit and annexures containing copies of the disputed publications and other material he relies on in support of his application.

In an order issued on October 6, 2026, Resident Magistrate Naima Kirui Chelangat ruled that no urgency had been demonstrated, directed that the application be served on Kiplagat and scheduled the matter for mention on October 27, 2026, for directions.

The court did not grant the interim injunction sought by Kirui in that order.

Disputed posts circulated in WhatsApp groups

According to Kirui’s supporting affidavit, the alleged publications were made on August 17, 2026, and circulated in the WhatsApp group known as North Rift News Hustlers before being shared or reposted in other groups.

Kirui identifies Cheptiret Development Forum and Cheptiret/Kipchamo Political Headquarters among the groups in which the material was allegedly recirculated.

One of the disputed posts, reproduced in the court documents, carried the heading “Worm Beneath Stone (6)” and referred to Kirui in connection with an alleged anti-government agenda.

The publication also made allegations about an individual described as an ICC witness, including claims that the witness had received money to give false testimony against President William Ruto, Joshua Sang and Henry Kosgey.

Kirui denies the allegations and argues that the statements falsely portrayed him as a person without integrity, a coached witness and a criminal.

He further disputes the claims that he was bribed to give false testimony at the ICC, describing the publications as damaging to his character, dignity and standing in society.

The allegations reproduced in the affidavit remain disputed claims by the applicant. The court documents reviewed do not establish that the accusations contained in the posts are true or that Kiplagat is legally liable for defamation.

Kirui says demand letter failed to stop publications

In his affidavit, Kirui says he issued Kiplagat with a demand letter requiring him to cease and desist from publishing allegedly defamatory or offensive material.

He alleges that the publications continued despite the demand, exposing him to ridicule, contempt and reputational harm.

Kirui argues that the continued circulation of the posts, particularly through WhatsApp groups with multiple participants, increased the potential damage to his reputation.

He maintains that the publications were false and that their circulation had adversely affected his image, dignity and standing in the community.

The activist has asked the court to issue interim injunctions restraining Kiplagat, his agents, servants or employees from publishing, posting or sharing allegedly defamatory or offensive remarks about him through WhatsApp groups, WhatsApp Status, Facebook, X and other social media platforms.

The requested orders are intended to remain in force pending the hearing and determination of the application and the main suit.

Kirui argues that continued publication could cause substantial harm that may not be adequately remedied through damages alone.

However, these are arguments advanced in support of his application, and the court has yet to determine the merits of his allegations or whether the injunction should be granted.

Second defamation case against Kiplagat

The latest proceedings place Kiplagat at the centre of two separate civil suits involving allegations of defamatory social media publications.

In the other matter, Boniface Kipchumba Biwott v Joshua Kiplagat, registered as MCCC/E2352/2026, Biwott accuses Kiplagat of circulating allegedly defamatory and offensive material about him through WhatsApp and other social media platforms.

According to the documents relating to that case, Biwott alleges that the publications portrayed him as a criminal and gangster, linked him to an ICC-related matter and questioned his association with human rights activists.

He also disputes alleged references to him as a “conman” and argues that the publications exposed him to ridicule, contempt and reputational damage.

Biwott is seeking interim court orders restraining Kiplagat and persons acting on his behalf from publishing or circulating similar material pending the determination of his suit.

The two proceedings are separate cases brought by different applicants. The allegations made in one suit do not establish the claims made in the other.

Court process to determine allegations

Kiplagat will have an opportunity to respond to the allegations through the court process. His response was not included in the documents reviewed for this report.

The case is scheduled for mention on October 27, 2026, when the court is expected to give directions on the proceedings.

About Author

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *